Category Archives: Why We Are Concerned

Will Duke Meet September 13th Application Deadline?

Duke continues their plans to pursue a transmission line through densely populated residential areas.  Here is what is happening:

September 13th is the due date for Duke’s Formal Application with the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).  It is unclear whether Duke intends to meet that deadline or make minor adjustments to their proposed routes, buying them extra time to file. Perhaps Duke is waiting to see if public outcry over the pipeline has diminished before they decide to file or delay.

One thing that is clear is that there has been no indication that Duke plans to locate the pipeline outside of densely populated residential areas.  Despite what they might want you to believe, the pipeline is still a very active project for Duke.  Here is what Duke of Ohio CEO Jim Henning and other Duke representatives have been working on these past few weeks:

  • Holding private individualized meetings with elected officials from affected municipalities
  • Still poking around people’s property on the original routes to survey and take soil samples
  • Conducting phone push polls with loaded questions to gauge public opinion on the project
  • Being totally evasive when directly asked by elected officials if they are looking at starting over on route placement.

From what we have heard so far, Duke likely will make minor modifications to their design and routing plans.  We do not expect it to be relocated to less populated areas.  Duke may even offer up a smaller, although still unacceptable, transmission line.  (Perhaps this was their plan all along?  Make it look like they are being responsive to public outcry?)

Duke would probably like to continue with plans to file their formal application by September 13th.   Negative responses from leaders and citizens could influence a delay.

What you can do to help:

  1. Check out this amazing new letter generator on the NOPE website! You fill in the blanks; it sends up to 15 copies of your letter to key officials on your behalf!
    Remember, the more letters we can submit before Duke’s deadline, the better our chance of making a difference!  Enter your address, choose which of your elected officials you want to send your message to, create a custom message and hit “send”.
  2. Sign this petition to enact legislation to keep natural gas transmission lines at least 1mile away from Ohio schools.
  3. Participate in our #NOPEtoDuke Twitter Campaign.  Send a tweet every day.  Let’s see if we can get our message to more officials and private citizens.

San Bruno Coverage As it Happened – September 9, 2010

The natural gas pipeline San Bruno, CA provides a good indication of what could happen in our communities if there is a pipeline failure.  The pipeline that exploded on September 9, 2010 was a 30″ pipeline, with about half the pressure of Duke’s proposed pipeline.  People initially thought there was a plane crash.  The explosion happened in a densely populated residential community, just like the ones is our area where Duke plans to build the pipeline.

 

 

 

San Bruno, CA – Pipeline Disaster in Populated Area

This is a sobering illustration of what would happen in our communities if Duke’s high pressure natural gas line failed.  This 30″ transmission line, just like the one Duke is proposing, was not installed in a densely populated area.  The community developed after the pipeline was installed as a result of urban sprawl. Why would Duke even consider creating a situation like this here?

Watch this.  This is why we are concerned.

 

San Bruno Analysis – 5 Years Later

April 29, 2016 Natural Gas Transmission Line Explosion

It was like looking into hell” – First responder

Date: April 29, 2016, 8:00 am

Location: Rural Salem, PA (31 sq. mi radius/pop. 6,500)

Injuries: Richard Johnston did not come into contact with any flames.  The heat from the explosion was so intense, it burned him inside his home ¼ mile away from the explosion.

Damage Description:  12 foot deep hole, 1500 sq. feet; scorched 44 acres

Issues: First responders could not get out of their emergency vehicles ¼ mile from explosion because heat was so intense.

Answers Elusive in Salem, PA Natural Gas Pipeline Explosion

Local eyes fixed on Spectra gas pipeline explosion/

Man burned in Salem Twp. gas line explosion; homes, businesses evacuated

Pipelines drained, evacuation order lifted as feds investigate cause of Salem Township explosion

PA Pipeline explosion: Evidence of corrosion found

 

Join NOPE! Cincy

High Pressure Transmission Lines

A transmission line is kind of like a super highway for moving massive amounts of gas across great distances.  The proposed transmission line through Hamilton County will either be supplied by similar transmission lines originating in the south, or transmission lines from the Utica and Marcellus shales.

The lines in your neighborhood are service lines, not transmission lines.  While size varies, service lines typically range from ½ – 2 inches in diameter.  The pressure in the service line when it reaches your house is less than 1 PSI.  Duke’s proposed 30 inch transmission pipe is a high pressure line containing 720 PSI in a single 1 inch cube.  But the real measure of the pressure in the pipeline is what is called total force…that equals 507,000 psi’s and a major explosion if the pipeline were to fail and ignite.

Join NOPE! Cincy